1 List Will Not Show In Subscribe! But 2 Public Lists Will?

New install of 3.3.1, everything seems to work fine!

The issue is that if I only have 1 list designated as public it will not show in the Subscribe page… If I have 2 public list they will both show in the Subscribe page… 2 list, 1 checked public and other not checked neither show!

I only need 1 public list and would like the other not listed on the Subscribe page…

What could be the issue?